What is the Difference Between Shame and Trauma?

I often get asked: What is the difference between shame and trauma?

Here is how I respond.

“Trauma is what is left within us when safety has been threatened. Shame is what is left within us when connection has been threatened.”

Here lies the clue to the deeper purpose of shame and why feeling it is one of life’s cosmic jokes.

Shame, the healthy kind that feels crap is something we can learn from. It doesn’t put us into a spin, it is meant to help us maintain healthy group cohesion.

The two main ways this operates are:

1. Shame helps maintain group cohesion

Early humans survived in small, interdependent groups. Being expelled or losing status in your group could mean death. No protection, no access to resources, no mates.

Shame acts as:

• An internal alarm about jeopardising group belonging.

• A way to regulate behaviour to match group expectations.

• A mechanism to avoid behaviours that might lead to exclusion.

Shame says: “If you keep doing this, you might lose your place.”

2. Shame discourages socially harmful behaviour

Before formal laws or external punishment, shame was an internalised regulator. It prevents actions that could:

• Endanger group harmony.

• Violate norms.

• Create conflict or distrust.

By feeling shame pre-emptively, people learn to avoid disruptive or morally questionable actions before others intervene.

This makes groups more stable and stability increases survival odds.

In ancient environments, shame was adaptive. Today it often overfires and is often triggered by:

• Unrealistic norms from a sick capitalist society.

• Norms formed from the patriarchy or white supremacy.

• Childhood development.

• Internalised family patterns.

• Systems that no longer serve survival.

So while shame evolved to protect us, it often now limits authenticity more than it secures belonging. Whilst some trauma, especially that caused by big one-off shocks or events, can often be things that we can apply a lot of body based strategies to heal from, shame requires something different.

Shame requires us to embrace the parts of us that we have exiled whilst some of the reasons for its existence may still carry on in our cultural container. We do this at a mind-body level and also at a much deeper soul level.

The soul is the one constant in all of this that can whisper us back home with the words “You belong.”

Stay connected

If you’re curious about shame, somatic healing or embodiment work, I’d love to stay connected.

→ Join my newsletter for reflections, free practices, and future online events.

→ Follow me on Substack for long-form writings on trauma, healing, and collective care.

→ Follow me on Instagram for gentle updates and more musings.